University of Barcelona
Full report: urban mobility strategies during COVID-19
Università di Bologna
Le città collaborative ed eco-sostenibili. Strumenti per un percorso multidisciplinare
Stefania Profeti, Giorgia Pavani, Claudia Tubertini
La collaborazione tra cittadini e amministrazione per finalità di interesse generale è ormai riconosciuta come nuovo modello di organizzazione e di azione delle città, da tempo protagoniste, sia nello scenario internazionale che interno, della progettazione e attuazione di interventi e politiche di inclusione sociale, tutela dell’ambiente, lotta ai cambiamenti climatici, sviluppo sostenibile fondati sulla partecipazione fattiva della cd. società solidale. Questo volume, frutto di una collaborazione consolidata tra le autrici, si propone di fornire una lettura sistematica di questo fenomeno in chiave multidisciplinare (diritto comparato, amministrativo e scienza politica), utile agli studiosi, agli operatori e agli studenti per comprendere gli elementi costitutivi di questo modello, gli strumenti normativi e di policy di cui si compone e le sue applicazioni concrete, attuali e future, nell’ottica della costruzione di città sempre più collaborative ed ecosostenibili.
UCLouvain
Private Ordering of Online Platforms in Smart Urban Mobility: The Case of Uber’s Rating System – Rossana Ducato
Rating and review systems are a self-regulatory mechanism widely used by online platforms, especially in the smart mobility sector. Such systems have already been analysed in empirical studies and legal contributions, in particular in the fields of consumer law, labour law and competition law.
This chapter aims to make an original contribution to the current debate from a relatively underinvestigated perspective: how rating and review systems interact with the European data protection framework. As a case study, the chapter will focus on the rating system adopted by Uber, one of the largest shared mobility platforms worldwide.
Sanctions on digital platforms: Balancing proportionality in a modern public square – Enguerrand Marique, Yseult Marique
This paper asks which legal tools digital operators could use to manage colliding rights on their platforms in a digitalised and transnational space such as the Internet. This space can be understood as a “modern public square”, bringing together actions in the digitalised world and their interactions with actual events in the physical world. It is then useful to provide this space with a discursive framework allowing for discussing and contesting actions happening on it. In particular, this paper suggests that two well-known legal concepts, proportionality and sanctions, can be helpfully articulated within that discursive framework. In a first step, proportionality, a justificatory tool, is often used to suggest a way for managing colliding rights. This paper argues that for proportionality to be useful in managing colliding rights on digital platforms, its role, scope and limits need to be better framed and supplemented by an overall digital environment which can feed into the proportionality test in an appropriate way. This can be provided, thanks to a second step, namely labelling in law the actions digital operators take as sanctions. Sanctions are the reactions organised by digital operators to bring back social order on the platforms. The labelling of these reactions under the legal category of “sanctions” offers a meaningful tool for thinking about what digital operators do when they manage colliding rights by blocking or withdrawing contents and/or accounts. As different types of sanctions can be distinguished, differentiated legal consequences, especially in relation to managing colliding rights, can be identified. Here the role played by the proportionality test can be distinguished depending on the type of sanctions. In any case, for sanctions and proportionality to help address colliding rights on the modern public square, a discursive framework needs to be developed, which depends on the existence of relevant meaningful communities engaging in reflecting on the use of sanctions and proportionality.
Gouverner par la loi ou les algorithmes: de la norme générale de comportement au guidance rapproché des conduites – Enguerrand Marique, Alain Strowel
Università degli Studi di Palermo
Presentations delivered at the Contrasting social inequalities through Sharing mobility event
Universitat de València
Journal number with results from the summer school
Being an influencer nowadays
Handbook for a non-discriminatory use of algorithms in public Administrations

Over the past decade, concern has grown regarding the risks generated by the use of artificial intelligence systems. One of the main problems associated with the use of these systems is the harm they have been proven to cause to the fundamental right to equality and non-discrimination. In this context, it is vital that we examine existing and proposed regulatory instruments that aim to address this particular issue, especially taking into consideration the difficulties of applying the abstract nature that typically characterises legal instruments and, in particular, the equality and non-discrimination legal framework, to the specific instructions that are needed when coding an artificial intelligence instrument that aims to be non-discriminatory. This paper focuses on examining how article 10 of the new EU Artificial Intelligence Act proposal may be the starting point for a new form of regulation that adapts to the needs of algorithmic systems.
Decisiones automatizadas: problemas y soluciones jurídicas. Más allá de la protección de datos – Alba Soriano
The growing implementation of algorithmic systems in all kinds of human activities is the result of their increasing computational capacity. These systems can process massive amounts of data and provide very accurate results that help decision-makers in both the public and private sector to classify humans and predict their actions. However, algorithms, and the actors that use them, are also increasingly producing significant harms to the fundamental rights of individuals and democratic principles and values. To date, informational privacy (data protection) regulatory frameworks, have been the main legal instruments tasked with protecting against the wide array of risks and harms caused by the automated processing of personal data. This paper maps the main hazards caused by algorithmic systems and aims to prove the shortcomings of the data protection framework in order to justify further regulatory intervention in the public and private use of auto-mated systems. It also draws a series of brief proposals that, were they to be implemented, should help to overcome some of the ineffective aspects of the current regulatory framework when dealing with the risks and harms caused by algorithms.
Decisiones automatizadas y discriminación: aproximación y propuestas generales – Alba Soriano
This paper focuses on the perpetuation of inequality through automated decision-making and profiling systems, analysing the ways in which equality and non-discrimination regulations, and to a lesser extent, data protection regulatory instruments, can prevent and address situations of algorithmic discrimination. In addition, the final part of the paper draws a general outline of possible proposals for the development of a legal framework that effectively controls and deals with the different risks and damages derived from the growing use of algorithmic systems, both in the public and private sectors.
The development of digital technologies, capable of analysing massive amounts of data, has led to the widespread implementation of data processing technologies and automated decision-making processes in many areas of human activity. Over the past few years, it has become increasingly apparent that these tools can cause significant harms to the fundamental rights of individuals as well as to other basic values and principles which constitute the very foundation of Western democracies. Most of the legal scholarship and regulators have thus far focused on privacy protection legal instruments as the main mechanisms through which to protect individuals and democratic values against the harms and risks caused by automated data processing and decision-making systems.
This book focuses on analysing how the EU data protection and US privacy protection frameworks are structured and can work in order to prevent and deal, in particular, with algorithmic discrimination, but also other issues of concern, such as automated system opacity. In doing so, the shortcomings of privacy-based protection systems in addressing some of risks and harms caused by data processing and decision-making technologies are also established. Finally, the book also draws a series of regulatory proposals aimed towards effectively addressing the concerns and problems that arise from the growing implementation of automated data processing and decision-making systems.


In this paper, it is argued that the algorithms used by the Public Administrations for the effective adoption of decisions must be considered administrative regulations from a legal point of view because they fulfil a function which is strictly equivalent to that of legal norms, i.e. to regulate and predetermine the action of the public powers. Additionally, it is studied which consequences can be deduced from this assumption in many areas: better regulation procedures for algorithms, complete publication of their code as it is legally binding for every norm and the necessity of legal remedies against algorithms. All these consequences, as stated in the text, represent a significant and necessary increase in relation with the current guarantees existing in our legal system.

